I loved it. It was a roller-coaster of emotion that has led me to think this is one of the best storytelling games I've played. That's my review.
I don't read reviews prior to playing.
I won't dismiss what others have said or feel everyone is entitled to their own opinions.
I haven't played every game ever made, my gaming history consists of only a few hundred games. So by all means please do disagree.
All I would say for people trying to decide if they should play it, go for it, form your own opinion and enjoy the ride.