If you enjoy hating popular things, being homophobic, being transphobic, having shallow and ignorant opinions, and disliking a sequel for the same reason you LIKED the first one (being ambitious), then you'll HATE this game.
If you're a true gamer, who appreciates not only an ambitious and expertly told story, exploring hard questions and the grey areas of morality, being deeply affected by performances and dialogue, etc. Fluid mechanics, visceral hand-to-hand combat, extensive and detailed animations, level design, etc. Then you will agree with most that this is a fantastic game, and quite possibly the best of our generation.