UPDATE: played through the game twice. First off if they make a 3rd game, UPDATE fist fighting, being able to switch locations of the off-hand holster on the gun belts as well. Also when you go back to the weapon wheel we should be able to set a certain knife as our main knife. For instance its fun to use the antler knife but time and time again it switches back to the normal knife. In fist fighting I want to be able to dodge and kick and tackle with separate buttons. And add dueling. I miss that in rdr2 from rdr1
I liked rdr 1 alot better because of the dueling and the overall feel of being in the wild west. There was just an awesome spark to rdr1
Rdr 2 is great and fun to play and amazing graphics, however it takes too long for everything, jumping on your horse (also how long for your horse to come to you). Looting takes way too long.... open drawer- loot- open drawer- loot - open cupboard- loot. Not sure why I have to spend 5-10 minutes looting a house in this game. Ain't nobody got time for that.
Too realistic as in you have to eat and maintain energy and stamina and dead eye.
Horse runs into things too easily. Bucks you off too easily and you can't mount up easily.
Also it's super easy to die at the hands of the police. Not to mention it is way to easy to get on their radar in Saint Denis.
For this reason I give 2 stars