Obviously I wasn’t expecting this film to be as good as Raiders and Last Crusade, and it wasn’t, but like Crystal Skull, I think this film is getting too much hate. I enjoyed it quite a lot, but it definitely has plenty of flaws.
The story isn’t really anything to write home about, it’s the familiar Indy formula of “set out on adventure to find (insert supernatural object name here)”. Simple, but still full of the fun, light-hearted whimsy he series is known for. Of course, the best part of every Indiana Jones film isn’t exactly the story, (with the exception of Last Crusade), but the action and humour. And this film absolutely delivers on both. The action scenes that felt most like Indiana Jones were definitely the opening train scene set in 1944, and the Tuk-Tuk chase. And I laughed out loud, SO many times during the film. The set design is also fantastic, I loved the Achamedis’ Tomb sets, with what appeared to be practical, running water.
Also, I didn’t really think that Indy was the “sad, broken old man” that many people being critical of this film seem to think he is. He can still hold his own and be the action hero he’s always been known as, despite his age now. And yes, Helena Shaw is a little bit too good at everything she does, but she doesn’t seem to be the overly strong show stealer that other critics have said she is. And the main villain isn’t the best, but still quite good, and fitting for Indiana Jones, given the fact he’s an ex-nazi, and the plan he has. So yeah, characters aren’t the best, but not as bad as critics are saying they are.
As I said though, this film definitely has plenty of flaws. And unfortunately, they do bring the film down quite a lot. Let’s start with the visual effects. I respect James Mangold for mainly relying on practical effects and stuntwork, but unfortunately, it wasn’t enough. I’m sorry, but the CG quality was awful, given how long it’s been around, and this film’s $295 million budget. I could always tell where CG had been used, and it unfortunately was overused. So many things that could’ve easily been filmed on location, in-camera, or with miniatures were instead CG, and they always stuck out like sore thumbs. Although I will proudly admit that the digital de-ageing on Harrison Ford in my opinion did look better than what practical make up and prosthetics could’ve done. But other than that, the digital effects were just no.
Also, this film is way too padded, it may not have felt as long as 154 minutes, but this film’s pacing is messy, and at least 30 minutes could’ve been shaved off, making this film the same length as all the other Indy films.
But overall, despite its flaws, I still had a fun time with this film. I’d rank it about the same as Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, which as I already said, I feel gets too much hate. Temple of Doom is still the weakest Indy film for me, but still good, and also as I said, this one was never going to top Raiders and Last Crusade. Definitely go watch this if you’re a big fan of Dr Jones. Indy and Harrison Ford’s final big screen adventure could’ve been FAR worse in my opinion, I mean, at least Indy wasn’t killed off like Luke Skywalker, Han Solo and Daniel Craig’s James Bond, though he admittedly did come close.
Final grade: B+