Sanjiv Shah

IDOL Season 12: Watching Indian IDOL for the first time. Missed all the other seasons. Let me begin by saying that this is a well produced show. Really a top notch production. Judges are very good. I have two comments to improve this show a little more. 1. Judges need to control their reactions while the contestants are on the stage and singing. Please do not interrupt, comment or even your body language needs to be controlled. This is one of the main reasons most candidates close their eyes while performing. They do not want to be influenced by judges reactions. 2. Producers: please stop bringing Bollywood non-singer celebrities. Vocalists, Lyricists, Composers, Poets are the best but not pure actors/actresses. They do not add value to the show. LP and Ajay/Atul were great but not Hemamalini or Dharmendra. If they have no singing background why would you bring them on singing competition show?