If I rated this based on the initial PC release it would be a zero star as I was one of the fools who pre-paid and had a completely broken game I couldn't play at all (it wouldn't even start).
However months later when the lesson about pre-ordering has well and truly been learned and many patches and hours of game play have passed, I can view this game objectively for what it is.
Rockstar know how to make a great game and this is no different. The voice acting, story and settings are all wonderfully done and all characters are believable and add to a very rich story.
While the game can be slow, things can heat up very quickly and you can find one small incident can escalate to a major fight for your life.
The game world looks and sounds fantastic, this game really takes graphics to the next level and while it looks amazing on consoles, it looks stunning on PC, if you have the hardware to crank up the settings. I have a 2080ti and 3700x but am pretty much always GPU bound and struggle to maintain 60fps @1440p at times and that is with some settings turned down as well!
This game is pure class, from production to story it shows how great Rockstar really are when they put effort into something. Hopefully they learned from the disastrous release though!