Just watched Dunki.
Decent one-time watch.
Definitely nowhere close to previous Raju Hirani classics (Munnai bhai, 3 idiots, PK etc)
Detailed review (with SPOILERS) below
What was good? – He’s picked up a good issue to make a movie on i.e. illegal immigration. Everyone has faced this directly or heard of it, where people try to move onto a better life. The story and characters used to depict this issue (on paper) is good. The montage at the end where they show stats related to illegal immigration, the desperation to get to better lives (with real-life footage) really tug your heart. The twist in the end when they all do a 'reverse Dunki' to get back is also smartly executed.
Vicky Kaushal was the best of the lot. Felt he was even better than SRK. The desperation and earnestness he shows to go to UK to rescue the love of his life comes across very strongly. Got a short role though.
What was NOT good?
A lot
For starters, the supporting cast was terrible. Not a single one of them strike a chord. You don't feel for them at ALL. In Munna bhai (Circuit), 3 idiots (Farhan, Raju, Chatur) were all brilliant characters with superb lines and portrayed by superb actors. Here the supporting cast was just outright annoying. Even the ever-dependable Boman Irani was so disappointing.
What kept annoying me all through the movie was the shoddy 'old people' make up used. Rather than an A-grade movie cast, they all (including Taapsee Pannu n SRK in their old avatars) looked like cheap Ramlila street actors on a tight budget. The old look just did NOT cut it for me. On similar lines, many of the village street scenes and the indoor shots all felt like a cheap set. Just didn't have a real feel. Why have directors forgotten that there is only so much that CGI, sets can deliver. If you want to give us a real-pind-di-feeling, pls go shoot in the pind !
Music was also very average. You don't walk out remembering even one song. And in Hindi movies, if you don’t have atleast 2 hit songs, straight away you know that the chances of such a movie being a hit go down by 50% straight away !!!
And frankly, public doesn't like SRK in any preachy, non-Raj type glamorous or non-Jawan like action hero role methinks. Unless it’s a Swades or a Dear Zindagi, he should just stick to his tried n tested template.
Hope this is not the start of the end for our beloved Raju Hirani and he bounces back with a much better movie soon 😊