I am aware of the fact that there are also plenty of Marvel fans who don't like Tobey Maguire's portrayal of Spider-Man. I saw some comments, saying that he's awful or the worst Spider-Man among the three actors who played the role. However, for me, Tobey Maguire is still the best! His 'Spider-Man' portrayal may not be the most comic-accurate due to his lack of naughtiness or being talkative (as what many Spidey fans said), but I do believe that he best portrayed Peter Parker as a shy, introverted, outcast but an intelligent student (I'm not 100% sure about this, since so far, I have never read any Spider-Man comics before and until now, but I'm really hoping to do so in the near future). I also read some comments that Spidey should be funny and naughty, but despite Toby Spidey's lackness of the said traits, his portrayal is still the best for me. I don't know, i just appreciated how he portrayed the role as if he's just a completely normal human being and you can feel the sad tone/vibes whenever he struggles with himself or with his love ones (Mary Jane, Aunt May, Harry, etc.)
Overall, i just love the whole tone of Sam Raimi's Spider Man trilogy, compared to the MCU version. I don't care if they say that Peter should be naughty or childish like Tom's portrayal, i still prefer Tobey's obviously quiet and shy portrayal with a touch of awkwardness.