Melissa Stern

I watched all of this show during its original airing and liked it, but when I rewatched, I realized how great it is. There were definitely some "misses" (I'm looking at you, Cordelia's storyline), but the last season really felt like they'd settled into a great direction. It's too bad they ended it, I'd really love to see how they got out of that final battle!!!

Superbly weird and hilarious. We frequently have to hit pause so we can finish laughing before the next joke hits!

Horrible. Terrible writing, terrible acting, and so so painful to watch. Why anyone is saying they love it is a total mystery. Can someone please stop greenlighting these "modern takes" on classics from Moffat and Gatiss? That last season of Sherlock... ouch.

I was super confused by the timelines at first, but I kept watching because it looks so cool and I love the characters. The music is pretty bad, though. I almost stopped watching after the second episode because of that song, and it didn't get much better after that, but again, the rest of the show didn't suffer from the songs as long as they kept them to the closing credits and I could turn it off. I still think the different timelines could have been done in a less clunky, less distracting way, but otherwise I'm ready for another season!