I'm gonna make this short.
Joel didn't deserve to die that way. You could make me play as Abby the whole game and I still wouldn't like her. Ellie losing her fingers and sparing Abbys life is so unsatisfying, since the whole point of the game is Ellie revenge of Joels death. The story and character development is garbage...
I would give it two stars but great graphics is not the only thing that makes a good game.