Josh Evans

Acting is not great from the leads. The side characters are better honestly, especially the girl from the first episode (not Ellie). I think Bella is only cut out for one dimensional acting or she’s being put in a box by writers/director. Same with Pedro portraying Joel, he’s neutered, uninteresting.

Excellent portrayal, loved every minute of it and will watch again and again! So happy that it's already been renewed. Keep it coming! Update: I'm not sure where "writers" and show-runners get their confidence to stray from source material but I wish they'd stop. If you want to do something original, great! Use your imagination and do something ORIGINAL. If you're going to dive into an existing universe, respect the author who knows WAY BETTER THAN YOU DO because he already has an enormous fan base. I don't get it. Pay attention to Denny V and Dune, or Peter Jackson and LotR. Do you know why they did so well? They stayed true to the story. Henry leaving was the death knell, it's a dead show. I hope someone more competent and respectful of the universe picks it up at some point and recasts Henry as Geralt, I even liked the actors for Yennifer and Ciri really well. Wasted potential.

Dennie V is the best director we have right now, protect him at all costs. This film builds on the first so well. Love the characters, love the music, love the visuals. THIS is a movie.

By far the worst of the 3 new films (if you can call them that). Terrible acting, writing, and story all around.

The best of the new trilogy, but still awful. Not sure what kind of lazy writing led to this.

Poorly written dribble. It's not even entertaining and a pain to watch.

Recasting due to guilty until proven innocent ruined this film. No thanks without JD.

After further time in the game, and seeing more about development, I've changed my mind. It's too bad, but it's disappointing on many levels.