I'll start off by mentioning that I completed this game and thus have grounds for my gameplay review. This is the most underwhelming game I have ever played in my life for so many reasons;
1. The camera control is disgustingly terrible. The developers cared more about capturing scenic photo shots than they cared about the gameplay quality itself. You cant ride your horse without having the camera 2 feet above ground level making it impossible to see anything
2. You will spend more time FINDING the colossi than you will actually fighting them. Most of the gameplay in this game is riding your mentally disabled horse who forces itself to run into every wall imaginable
3. Every colossus fight is exactly the same. Every single fight could end in 5 minutes if the developers didn't stall out the fights by forcing you to go through multiple battle sequences. You spend the first 20 minutes of the fight scaling buildings to jump on the colossus, then once you finally get on the thing, you get thrown off and have to spend another 20 minutes to get back on
4. Swimming in this game is as slow as they could possibly have made it in a sad last ditch attempt to make the game longer than it needs to be. Why am I forced to swim at a rate of 1ft/hour in a boss fight that is ENTIRELY IN THE WATER?
5. The "puzzles" in this game are hardly puzzles at all. Not a single puzzle in this game can be solved through pure intuition alone. Be ready to have a guide open next to you at all times or you will go mentally insane from how degenerately non-linear and irrational these "puzzles" are. Once you read how to complete a puzzle, I can guarantee you will be baffled by how it makes literally NO SENSE at all. Once again as it seems to be a common trend in this game, to draw out the lacklustre gameplay
In conclusion, I could go on and on about this game but I think you get the point by now. I did the suffering for you and played this game to its end. Do not waste even a minute of your life playing this building climbing, suicidal horse riding, puzzle googling simulator