I rate it 4 because of few scenes which could have been made better. Let me first tell you that majority of people will rate this low, even young crowd would love to read a book on this over a movie. As we always expect movies to spoon feed you the story with a clear lines meeting when it comes to Romantic genre. The death scene could have been avoided or modified but which would have stretched the length. The ending was well explained i.e a Loop. But could have been better presented. Otherwise the story, concept or the depth as the title goes Gehraiyaan, was very well depicted. Keep making many such. 4 is on the higher end, to keep supporting such Romantic thrillers which brings in the condition a Men and Women goes through. Very balanced writing. Loved it✌️