I assume all these reviews are of folk that left their passion for what Tool stood for, back in 2006 with 10000 Days and forgot who they were.. The album was rubbish.. Not one track had balls, substance or any degree of metalish tones. "They've matured as a band", people claim.. If you're a true fan of a genre, band or song - it will always resonate truely. If you're a fan for a reason, a season or because of particular company, then you probably don't like their older stuff anymore anyway - you know, the stuff that made them world renowned and built an empire of followers.. Again, not a decent riff, breakdown, scream here. Maybe because of the lazy "remote production" they chose to fund retirement.. How can you have that joint energy without a complete band..?!