I really wanted to like Tick Tick Boom, but to be honest, it really doesn't work as a movie. The problem with a movie being essentially just a tribute to a person (and also, an industry, such as Broadway) is how despite how sincere and effervescent it is, what gets lost along the way is SUBSTANCE and PLOT. Tick Tick Boom is all style and no substance. And let's also be honest, most of Larsen's lyrics and songs were...really bad. Like, really bad as in, insufferable, and really clunky and annoying lyrically and musically. The only musical number that was actually good and memorable was "Therapy" because it's here where FINALLY, they give us some insight into some actual emotion between the characters (Larson and his girlfriend) in the heat of an argument, but like everything else about this movie, the energy is so chaotic and frenetic and hyper that even the smallest glimpse into something deeper goes missing in the whiplash of it all. And that diner scene? Cute, but a tad bit cringe/awkward as it did absolutely nothing to keep the plot going, it was a bunch of Broadway theatre cameos for Broadway theatre cameos sake.
Maybe the main reason why Tick Tick Boom also does not work as a movie is because it was never designed to be one. It was a one man show, so it literally felt like a stretch to take this material and have it run for almost 2 hours. Andrew Garfield makes an uncanny Larsen, but all the hype with his singing I don't understand, his singing is passable but not THAT good. I loved all of the minor characters of color, but unfortunately they are underutilized here (especially the fabulous MJ of Pose), we really don't get to know them, nor even Larsen himself to who he was as a person, not only as a creative. It tries to do so much with the really overedited, over the top musical performances, but none of them really are convincing, they don't say much about anything and don't really move the plot along that much. There was some reference to the HIV/AIDS crises, but it felt cheap. It may have indeed inspired Larsen as many of his friends were dying from the virus, but the way it was done here felt exploitative and manipulative as aside from having Silence = Death posters in the background for a split second, there would be no mention of ACT UP, no archival footage/news clips from the epidemic, no meaningful exploration of how Larsen might have felt about this virus and how it has taken his queer friends, nothing, the epidemic was essentially used as garnish to force emotion into the story only to not be explored at all or mentioned again so they could focus instead on Larsen singing for the billionth time about how it sucks to turn 30. We get it, its Larsen's story, but the biggest issue with treating the epidemic as a backdrop of emotional convenience is how it doesn't do the character or the story any favors, it makes his privileged problems and constant whining about not being famous like Sondheim even more meaningless. It was a real wasted opportunity that deserved to be fleshed out more instead of tacked on and then brushed aside. What this "movie" really needed was to SLOW DOWN. There was never any moment where we actually got to know any of these people, there was never a time when they'd let us feel emotions organically, it felt like very aggressively, they'd try and make us feel something when it should have come from a place of something natural, not forced. It's a shame because there is a lot of promise and talent here, but it's too much navel gazing and idol worship to make Tick Tick Boom as entertaining, fun, and meaningful as it thinks it is.