Alison Goldberg

Reads like a fan fiction and lacks the depth of the first seven. Things like gilly weed readily available and just more emotional than natural in the dialog. The dialog is boring or over stated and repeating events in the original seven than adding much new content. The plot was also pretty lame too. Makes Ron out to be a joke. Unimaginative and doesn’t feel like it really came from JK Rowling’s herself. Feels off.