I've played both games and I'd say I prefer the first game story wise. A true old-y but good-y. I really did prefer the voice acting in this first game as well, Sebastian sounded more like what you would think a gruff, grieving Detective in a place called Krimson city would sound like, and the voice acting overall just seemed more authentic than in the sequel. That being said, this is an old game so glitching, tropes and old graphics beware.