I think this is perhaps one of the most haunting war films I have ever seen, and as far as WWI goes, is on a par with "Johnny Got His Gun". Peter Weir does a masterful job pulling us into the lives of very young men who are full of energy, vigor, and humor. He, and the actors portraying the main characters, get us to love their youth and their innocence. Like so many young men, their idea of war is very immature and based on second-hand accounts. They have no idea what is awaiting them, only that this is an adventure they must experience. Mark Lee is breathtaking: So handsome, lively, with an easy smile and a laugh. You just fall in love with him. His death, at the end, is a brutal slap to your face. You feel helpless, devastated by the sudden and silent end to a life so full of promise. I have heard others complain that not enough time was spent filming the actual war scenes. This is what war is like in the lives of these young men: Alot of waiting and preparing, the experiences and people they meet, only to get there and have everything over so quickly. So many veterans of so many wars talk about this same experience: Remembering long periods of boredom and attempts to amuse themselves, followed by battles that seem, to them, to last such a short amount of time. Peter Weir is a master filmmaker, and this film is one of his masterpieces (in addition to Witness), where he uses silence so effectively (the scene where Lukas Haas points out the murderer in the bustling police precinct is simply bone-chilling). The final scene of this film does the same thing: It makes you want to cry out with shock and disbelief at how quickly and silently war erases youth.