Melissa Hernandez

It was cute, a little bit of an odd plot twist with the siblings switching partners with the other siblings as if it’s not weird. I felt like that was glazed over and wasn’t developed enough to make it believable. I thought it was gonna be about the family being wrong for judging Meredith and Everett’s comparability by being pleasantly surprised at the end… but no. Everett meets Meredith’s sister and immediately falls in love with her? weird. They literally talk like one time and he already has the googly “I’m in love” eyes like please lolll Then Meredith forms a relationship with Ben at the same time Everett and Julie are “falling for each other” but before, when Ben meets Meredith, he also immediately shows interest in her as if his BROTHER didn’t just bring her home. When Meredith finds out Everett wants her sister, she’s not enraged enough for me. She doesn’t even confront her sister like bffr lol When Julie is about to get on the bus, she doesn’t want to stay but she doesn’t say that it’s wrong bc Everett was literally about to marry her SISTER, her excuse for not staying is bc “it’s too much!” Like please lmao they don’t really address it, everyone was just so nonchalant about that, which is unrealistic. I know it’s a movie, but this storyline was kinda silly considering they didn’t spend more time developing it. I liked it up until that plot twist, i wouldn’t consider this a Christmas movie i’d watch every year.

I enjoy this movie, i don’t know why the reviews are saying it’s unrealistic as if it’s not a movie? Lol anyway, it’s one of my favorite cozy holiday movie’s except for the casting, the romance is there but only for jude and cameron’s characters tbh. Jack blacks and kate winslet’s characters have zero chemistry and it’s so obvious. It looks so forced, when they kiss for the first time it’s so awkward and it just looks very acted, especially jack black. At the end when they hug it looks like they’re going in for a kiss but kate ends up dodging it and nuzzles his neck instead lollll that honestly ruins it for me and i normally get distracted during their scenes.

I watched it last year for a pre screening and couldn’t wait for it to be finalized. I watched it again and loved it!

Meh. Really disappointed. This movie is so rushed and random, like how they just ran into Elizabeth in the woods and on the boat? I figured it’d be a good movie since it had William Moseley and Loreto Peralta but nah. Elles character was honestly not even needed in the movie since they give no background...Actually, none of the characters have backgrounds lol which makes the storyline flat, confusing, and boring. Another thing that annoyed me was the wizard’s horrible acting, his evilness was not believable. At. All. Watch at your own risk LOL