It’s about 7/10.
Yes, I agree with some of the more the negative reviews it could have been way way better … I know what you are saying and I feel your pain. I do sincerely.
However.
Even though it irritated me a little in the way it lacked quite a bit of depth and detail. The other thing that bothered me a bit was the focus on far too much (understatement) surrounding the love life between Napoleon and Josephine.
The overall run time didn’t really need to be this long, in essence of the actual message the movie attempts to project from itself. The movie wastes and doesn’t value your time in some respects I feel. This will garner hate with some critics.
Still with all that said, it’s still pretty damn good war movie!
I loved the grittiness / the gore / the grotty time period. The sadness, the ego, the vengefulness, the greed and a whole lot more.
The movie projects these traits & qualities of human nature very well, with the battle scenes being executed reasonably well exuding the terror and sacrifice as they capture the dread and fear inducing despair (of the troops and the time period) remarkably well.
But …Yes….
It could have been so much more…
I think by comparison with real life - think saving private Ryan level - it could have been epic. It could have been a 9-10/10 easily. But it was a 6/7 dare I say 7.5/8.
No more than this. Regarding ratings (just in my opinion) 8 is being too generous. 5 would be too harsh, 6 is a bit evil.
It was a snippet of a movie compared to his life and what he achieved and probably the actual battles that took place. I wasn’t at the battle of Waterloo (surprisingly 😂) but speaking as an ex military person I imagine to capture that on a movie set would be ridiculously difficult unless we are to be whisked off to CGI land extraordinaire.
The movie isn’t anywhere near as epic or as real true to life as it would have taken place in real life. This movie by Ridley Scott (big fan btw) doesn’t show the sheer magnitude very well as if would have been. You get a glimpse and a live story here thrown in with a good helping of boring side politics (just my opinion).
I feel I’m playing the old call of duty here (no check that - Medal of honour games) and I now am ready to be a soldier and fight in wars, it’s a bit like that.
It’s a bit shallow, the story has bits inaccurate and missing. They could have focused more on building out the battles a bit more (larger forces at play here in truth than what the movie does show) and maybe focusing in on the more famous generals, commanders and the aristocracy / royals of the time - they only touched on this.
The real history would have been a whole lot more terrifying / potent and intersting.
The film portrays about 30% of it and some will say 10% 😂
But overall if you go in thinking ‘I want to be entertained’ you will be…. Albeit rather mildly with some better bits here and there. It’s that sort of movie.
Dare I say it bored me in some places and I found myself googling the real historic events which wowed me a bit more and as a refresher in between movie scenes which probably means I lacked a bit of interest.
My rating 7/10 and that’s being rather generous I feel.
And I say the 7/10 as a huge Ridley Scott fan, a huge fan of history and historically depicted movies.
People will be arguing the inaccuracies I fear in this one for a while to come…..