Well, I wasnโt a theater buff in school nor out of it, except the occasional musical done on film. Iโd say I am definitely not Disneyโs target audience for this show. That being said, I found โEncoreโ to be surprisingly easy to watch. The former high school drama club members spotlighted in each episode manage to mostly pull off a functional version of their musical, but you didnโt come here to watch โstarsโ. This show is actually about real people who live normal lives and are briefly given a shot to do what most never get to do, โgo back againโ, and the drama these reunions may cause.
The most fascinating part of the series has been learning how individuals struggled or succeeded post HS, and unresolved issues and conflicts that arise during taping. I havenโt seen anything over the top, ridiculous arguments or staged drama yet, so hereโs hoping Disney keeps this show on the level. My only 2 complaints are: 1) I feel like each episode is too short, because they are trying to juggle reunions, personal drama, practice, and the final show, all in less than 1 hour. My advice would be to dive deeper into the human interactions, and less about the musical itself, which would create a more compelling drama for the audience (or just make it longer). The stilted editing pace results in many story arcs without any form of resolution, so even covering them to begin with seemed like a waste of time. 2) Iโve noticed some repetition in the format. People reunite, air initial grievances / memories, dumb โpracticeโ singing session (that only exists to embarrass the performers I think), roles cast, practice, some personal drama is revealed, practice, show airs, people do โgood enoughโ, end. This repetitive narrative style may cause me to lose interest in the show quickly, but Iโll keep at for a few more episodes, at least.