I've only played 8 hours so far, so my opinion is probably not as concise as it could be, bearing in mind that it's probably 8 hours more than most of those who gave 0 stars.
So far the games been fantastic, the visuals splendid, game play similar to its predecessor but equally as good. The talking point for the negative reviews seem to be regarding the "story", which I believe is captivating and suspenseful, creating a great sense of adventure.
It's easy to see the "story" in poor taste if you're relying on just leaks or clips of certain scenes, which almost takes the scene out of context. It seems a bit unfair to judge the game on that basis without giving it a chance.
GG