In the same way your dad would say - I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed.
I can't stop thinking that with 1 billion dollars this is the best that could be created?
There is some very uninspiring scriptwriting, extremely disappointing CGI (do the artists understand how sunlight is supposed to look?!?), some B grade sets (a ship on the ocean shouldn't look like it was crafted that minute, without a scratch upon the timber or salt damage or any kind of deterioration), some very unremarkable casting...
LOTR is such a rich vein of story telling to mine, yet this falls so far short of the mark that it's quite surprising. 5 episodes in and I still don't really understand the thrust of the story - what exactly am I supposed to be afraid of? Who am I supposed to believe in and cheer for? It's all just so thin....
Episode 5 felt like something made by a fan of Glee. And that is the last thing this should feel like.
Aesthetically - although there's some good production design and great costumes....the overall visual style is so far removed from reality as to leave the viewer disconnected because nothing looks tangible. Nothing looks like a world that could be inhabited in reality. Perhaps this is the aesthetic people enjoy in 2022, but for me, I find something far more engrossing when what I see looks like something I could touch. Something I could exist in. That aids the suspension of disbelief and ignites the imagination. Rings of Power is obsessed with a constant golden hour, oversaturation of colours at every moment, and such poor green screening as to be shocking. To say I expected better from the most well funded show in history is an understatement.
It should be so much better. The films were far from perfect, but they contained a lot more guts than this will ever get close to. Two thumbs down.