I am a die hard hard of the books. At first, I was quite disappointed by the film because the story is massively different from book 1 given Arty was supposed to be cold-hearted and all but separating the book from the movie, it's amazing. It's fun and quirky. I just hope that the Butler scene was more real (Butler was supposed to kill the troll and maybe some blood wd be nice). All in all, I'm still looking forward to sequels and hoping for a better one and more true to books. The audience will surely love it.