I thought I'd written a review back when this first came out but I guess not! I've watched this movie probably 2 dozen times by now and it simply doesn't get old. This is one of my favorite movies ever, Christian-themed or not! I laugh and cry every time I watch it. So, what makes it so good?
First, Brett Dalton's performance is stellar: he's so genuine, so believable, so authentic, and so relatable, that you can't help but root for him. His chemistry with Anjela Johnson is terrific! It's so fun to see her play a "straight-man" character, knowing she's a comedian, yet she gets in plenty of hilarious looks and lines. They work so well together as their characters develop a true friendship, probably one of the few (if any) Gavin's ever had.
The rest of the cast, rounded out by long-time professionals like DB Sweeny, Neil Flynn, and even Shawn Michaels, means we're treated to a very professional production despite it being a "Christian film".
The themes in the movie are terrific! As someone else mentioned, the line said twice, "This is what we do" really hits the central themes: forgiveness, second chances, true friendship, and most of all, grace.
The movie has many funny and poignant moments, and they're tied together nicely with good directing and some great songs in the soundtrack.
10/10 for sure. If you've hesitated to watch a Christian-themed film that mentions Jesus, and shows the story of his birth, life, death, and resurrection, please give this non-preachy, funny, thoughtful movie a try. You won't be disappointed!