Not really fond of the inventory issues, lack of direction doesn't help, so far I just feel like I'm climbing the same tower like structure to do the same thing, all I got from the story so far is that you're lost at sea, and some big turtle looking creature pops up to say hi even now and then.
The initial rowing feels like it takes an age to get somewhere, which is great for immersion, but not for my index finger holding the bloody button down!
I like the random island generation, the combat is a bit clunky.
I really like the survival aspect of it, managing health and hunger.
Not amazing, but not terrible, had some pretty funny bugs so far which made me smile.