I watched all six available seasons of this... I have no idea why.
At first it's an interesting look into a world that might not be too familiar... high school football and inner city living. But the characterization makes me hate everything I just witnessed.
This show is a roller coaster of soap opera drama with highs and lows where people in one scene might be the good guy voice of reason and in the next scene be irrational and against any reason. It gets old, fast. It's cliche... when a big game is coming up... you know who is going to win... when they introduce a bad character, you know exactly what the bad character is going to do... it's highly predictable.
But the very basic, borderline-teen drama wasn't what killed this for me... what did it is the characters. I liked one person in this. Only one person makes mistakes early as an evil person and comes back to redeem themselves through tireless introspection and self-less actions. Everyone else does at least one extremely awful thing and gets a total pass for it.
To illustrate my point, I will focus on the twin sister character... Olivia Baker... she's awful... she's self-righteous, privileged, and does horrible things throughout this series and gets a pass every time because of how "special" she is. That's the main character, too. I think her exotic good looks do a LOT of heavy lifting for her character. She gleefully breaks up a functional relationship out of a sense of entitlement and we're supposed to go along with it, because she is the hot main character.
This show wants to show that anyone can achieve anything special regardless of how hard their circumstance, yet it argues that these characters are born special and that great things aren't a matter of hard work and commitment, rather they are a thing of destiny.
For supporting characters, it's all about the work they put in and earning that special status... but for the main characters, every line of dialog addressed to them tells them they are special even when they aren't putting in the work. Even when they are actively destroying the collective plan.
Which brings me to another very sophomoric problem this show has... is that a lot of the drama is perpetuated by a normally rational person suddenly, irrationally, going against the group plan. Shows do this a lot... the Walking Dead was full of it... where everyone in the group comes to a solid plan that everyone agrees on, to deal with whatever... yet one person in the group "just has to do this thing..." that they can't tell anyone about, that contradicts the plan, the whole time telling everyone they are onboard with the plan. It's lame, artificial drama. Once and a while it's OK, but that's every situation in this show.
There isn't a drama situation that occurs that isn't handled like this... the group comes up with a plan, but one person in the group just has to do things their own way, because they know more than the group. It always fails, and in the end they always apologize... but I never feel like anyone, (again, except one character), no one learns anything.
I certainly didn't. This is a bad, soap opera. I watched it all simply because I have way too much time on my hands. It really is that.