I’ve been a fan of these characters for a long time, so I was genuinely excited when I heard they were finally getting their own spin-off. Unfortunately, after watching it, I’m left disappointed. The dynamic the writers have given them as a couple feels off; the show comes across as formulaic and, honestly, a bit dull.
What’s hardest for me is how it seems to undo so much of what Tony and Ziva went through together. Their bond in the original series was built through years of shared struggle, and that depth should naturally have carried over. Instead, the trauma and distance between them feel forced. And because we all know they’ll eventually reconcile, even that resolution will likely feel forced instead of earned.
I really wanted to love this show — I still love these characters — but right now the writing just isn’t doing them justice.