While perhaps it's not as great as the original, nonetheless, I found it to be a pretty nice live action remake.
From the very beginning, it's noticeably different in both tone and even setting. Some may complain about it, but after hearing how different the Studio Ghibli anime film was from the original book it was based off of, I decided to accept it as the ongoing trend. Granted, I've never read the original book, so I can't say for sure how different it was, but I feel like SG made no mistakes when they made their changes, giving their film its own unique charm and themes that still sticks by me today.
With that being said, the movie is little darker, more serious, and more "realistic" in a sense than the anime counterpart - and I like it. SG's Kiki placed her in a world where she was somewhat easily accepted into society, and how all the people there were kind. In this version, however, not everybody was as kind as they first appeared, with some even straight up disliking Kiki for who she was. In the end, Kiki had to work hard to be accepted by everyone, with her saving the day with Tombo to prove her character and worth to her new home.
Speaking of Tombo, I actually like how different he was in this film. In this film, he straight up disliked Kiki from the start, but after she saves his life after a botched flying attempt, he grows to understand her more, and bonds with her after he teaches her a bit of his "magic." He helps her on the road to personal recovery, giving her a spark of hope that she could get better.
I was pleasantly surprised that they did throw in another witch into this story, and she had her part to play. A witch who chose to be a musician, she had lost her voice after losing her sister to a storm, and chose to live in isolation with her niece who may or may not one day learn under her aunt and Kiki in the future. Teaching Kiki an important lesson when it came to their powers, it took her a while for her to fully understand that while they can lose their powers, they can get it back, and in the end, their power came from within, not from the broom, as everyone had mistaken, even Kiki. She even returns around the end to give Kiki the support she needed, which helped her fly and save the day.
As for Kiki herself, well, for one, I feel like Fuka Koshiba did a pretty good job on portraying this version of Kiki. Yeah, she's not exactly like the Kiki I know and love, but I think that's the point. This live action adaption wasn't meant to be an exact clone of the movie, and yes, while perhaps she could've been a bit more likeable, in the end, she was doing her best in a society that was unsure of what to think of her, so it's natural that she would have a hard time being "likeable" to others (in other words, the other characters.) Besides, SG Kiki was a bit cold to others anyways, particularly to Tombo, since again, she was unsure how to fit in and mingle.
Then there's Jiji, our favorite black cat. Assumedly created from pure CG (and perhaps some puppetry), while the effects for him wasn't great, it was still pretty good nonetheless, and while he doesn't have as much of an impact to the story and her character in this movie, he still did play an important role as her mentor and friend, trying to give her advice that she didn't listen to.
Overall, I would give this film a 7/10. I'm happy that they made Kiki into live action, and I'm happy that they did a pretty decent job of it, especially considering how they tried to make it more unique in its own way.