(contains spoilers) As a franchise fan I really liked the movie, BUT I found it a little illogical in a few scenes. When Predator was fighting french colonists, he was such a badass ripping all them apart, but he couldn't handle native american girl? I mean didn't he have anything up his sleeve that would plotwist things a bit, she basically didn't get a scratch from a monster and she seemed too superior over an intergalactic hunter.
Then this scene when the girl went to take her dog and axe from french colonist camp, she got attacked by those french folks and basically teared them to pieces, no rolling on a grass and fighting till last breath, it really seems strange, because when a lion attacked her on a tree she felt on a ground and lost consciousness, making her look quite fragile and then when it came to fight colonists she was superior like John Wick from a forest, so there could be a bit of scaling up or something introduced in between.
Why did the girl cut the French colonist leader's leg? She said it's because they caught her brother, but I mean really why to just cut the leg and how she thought in advance to use it as a bait? Maybe she could just be injuring french slowly, while he was tied by a tree to get Predator's attention with screams as it would have looked like she 'caught her prey', that i guess makes more sense following the movie's line.
One of the last scenes made me raise an eyebrow, like Predator forgot how his own gun works? Why was he pointing at her with his arrow gun even though he didn't know where he was targeting as he didn't see his own laser dots which those arrows were to follow? If Predator lost the mask, he knew that he would eventually miss his shot to a girl and how girl knew that these lasers will work against Predator, it just didn't make sense, It would have been more sensible if there was some sort hole with spikes, left by colonists to hunt bears, Girl traps Predator to fall into that pit, he sees he has no chances and he activates self destruction bomb, Girl escapes by jumping in a lake or something, yada yada.
Males that supposedly are the top people in the tribe seemed so weak, they are top hunters in the group who have to have lots of strength, then these folks in the film looked so pale and lacking of muscle reminded me of young teens who just stepped outside their rooms from playing computer games, they could at least hit a gym for couple months before film shooting started. I didn't see any horses, but they were such a huge part of Native American culture at those times, directors could explore better Native North American tribe history and reflex it more profoundly in the film.
Then this little animal killing, like really Predator tore out snake's spine? Give me a break, it seems like this Predator is super junior or inexperience by showing him hunting small animals like wolves and snakes as predators usually target apex creatures.
Btw, where is this Mayan worshipping Predators as gods thing where they were sacrificing villagers to breed Aliens so Predators could fight them, haven't Native North American tribes encountered that following predator's lore?
Script could have been improved as it seems that it was written quite lazy, unprofessional way. Overall it's an ok watch, bearable, but lots of those 'why' were coming up for me, so I can't give more than 1 star as these new creators degraded Predator's lore continuity which is not acceptable for many fans.