Matthew McAteer

I saw the original Off-Broadway adaption "Shakespeare's R&J" which is the inspiration for this film. The stage production was more focused and pared down, four actors, black box theater, set in an unnamed boy's school, a few chairs, or benches were the extent of the set (if I recall correctly). There were also few props, but to this day I can vividly recall how they used a red piece of cloth to great affect. The minimalism of the production allowed the viewer to focus on Shakespeare's words, and the interaction of the boys and their characters. That said, Private Romeo, though a bit overwrought in its military academy setting, is still a fine adaptation of this particular retelling of Romeo & Juliet. The acting is outstanding, especially Numrich, Doyle, and Appleman. The score (except for some odd videoesque scenes) enhances the emotional development of the characters and the arc of the story. The cinematography, lighting, and production quality were all done well. The direction of the actors was great, but I think the director tried to load the story up too much with what seemed like some social commentary on homosexuality and military culture. In the end, for me it is about the Shakespeare's beautiful words, and here the movie delivers.