I give the game an honest 3 stars. I played since beta and it would be 5 except that bethesda nerfed the pvp aspect into the ground instead of making passive work correctly. I know of hundreds of people that have left because of this. What I liked early on is that it was really difficult to run through alone, now after one wasteland its excruciatingly easy. When I go to an event there may be one or two enemies per spawn, it use to be dozens. I fear that bethesda has catered too much to the people that cried for an easy button.
If I were able to defend my low level pve teammate or have team pvp again id easily give this game 4.5 stars. 5 if there was content and it was a challenge