First two episodes we're meh but it goes downhill fast after that. Awful writing, terrible acting, and just boring. While there are some cool sets, costumes, and FXs, there are also a lot of extremely cheap sets, costumes, and FX mixed in which often ruins the vibe and makes show feel cramped/obviously shot in studio.
The biggest issue with the Acolyte is there is no logic or consistency behind any of the characters or their actions. The shallow writing, constant plot holes, and sub-par delivery make it impossible to get invested in what happening. So the story sucks and there is essentially no action to keep things exciting. There is literally just one 5 min fight scene in episode one. For the next 5 episodes there is absolutely no action or anything other than excruciately bad dialog until half-way through episode 6. There is a decent fight scene here but as soon as they start talking again you remember how god awful this show. Who keeps hiring these awful writers in Hollywood?
With Disney's stock plummeting and Bob Iger recently telling fans and investors the company would be focusing more on quality for the past year, I am shocked Disney execs allowed this to be released in such an awful condition. The Acolyte cost a lot more to produce than The House of the Dragon per minute yet the Acolyte looks like a cheap student film next to it. This is easily the worst Star Wars IP i've ever seen (and i've seen it all). Disney is obviously hiring the wrong creatives (and paying them too much) and the executives have awful taste (not to mention out of touch with their customers) if they think it's acceptable to approve a script like this - let alone release a final product that is this bad for such a storied IP. Really sad to see Disney fall off like this (while dragging great IP down with them). They had such a solid run.