Robert Allen

I don't know whose bright idea tonights show was but I think it is a shame that when this years contestants are nearing the end of the fight of their lives in order to win American Idol someone throws a very BAD idea in on them. If the producers want to have a come back show then they should do that. The final contestants from this year should not have to compete against contestants that didn't make it in their own year. If one of these people win then I feel that it will be a shame. They had their chance and should not take away from one of this years contestants.