Great book but I have some comments. First of all, the cats spent too much time arguing about the journey to the lake, over half the book, and also, why do all of the cats all of a sudden turn so rude and mean? Yeah, there were some bullies in the Prophecies begin, but this... When the characters talk they always use words like Growl, hiss and snarl, and even the kind cats be mean. Aside that, this is a great book considering the breathtaking journey.