I have mixed feelings about this book, though I like it overall. I liked Edward's point of view (since I have read all the Saga books) and it gives a fresh perspective on so many things. I found Bella to be more likeable from Edward's point of view & how he notices every tiny emotion about her. I liked the gaps which were filled & which we never knew were there from the PoV of Bella, because Bella didn't know everything. I also liked Edward's mind-reading part. However, at times, the mindless internal ramblings went on too much and the story could have been filled with more perspective on Alice, Jasper, Carlisle and the rest though it did give additional information on most of them. Even then, I wanted more perspective on the Volturi & Edward's life as a mortal & an immortal. The book could have more depth to it. Other than that I think I liked this book is good and if u like Edward, you will like it too. It's not exceptional but it does make for a good read.