Firstly l loved the book ,it going to be on my top list . It made me cry like oceans , l don't remember when l cried that much before not even when my cat died and u know what l was prepared before reading this book that l am going to get hurt but now l know how much devasted l am right now . You know l still excuse ryle's mistake because at that point l was deeply in love with him that l could do anything to be in his arms. I hate myself for wanting him but my stupid heart doesn't listen. I think ryle was the best husband and dad ,it just his angry issues that aren't even in his control destroyed him. I would never doubt his love for lily never because he loved her deeply and truly. He just need someone better who would stand with him and fight his demons from the past . Lily and Atlas both deserve each other and l am really happy for them . Atlas waited for so long and finally after this long journey he found his destination, lily. Happy ever after