Personally, I loved it start to finish. This is not an album, it is an experience. They captured so many different things and fused them together in a way that makes this album feel unpredictable and imaginative, and I for one am into that. The album really showcases their overall musical ability in a lot of different settings and I've always been a big fan of musicians that can make music of all styles, rather than the one trick ponies. This is pretty much their musical equivalent of Dark Side of the Moon, that's the closest comparison I can think of. I personally love the trip that is "Life Is But A Dream". If you're looking for Hail to the King 2.0 or City of Evil Part 2, you will be greatly disappointed here.
Most replayed songs for me have been Cosmic, Mattel, Death, Nobody and Easier. I may be biased but I give it a 10/10. Powerful and bold move by Avenged Sevenfold, amazing job.