I’m 160 pages in and every few pages I can’t help but audibly say “this is so dumb”. I will delete this review if I like it by the time I finish the book. But so far, it’s the worst Penelope Douglas book I’ve ever read. The characters are so unlikeable and DUMB, and the story has no logic behind it. “THIS IS SO DUMB”. Btw if you get squeamish at the thought of mouth piercings, move along and read a different book. Maybe Credence and Birthday Girl just set my standards too high.