Mary Helen Organ

Garrett is an very good actor but even he and Mark Walburg couldn't pull this off. It had a lame script and story line. I'd like to see Garrett in more movies where he sings. I love to watch him sing.

I really liked it. I could identify with the actor William. He's a really actor. My only critique was the ending. Does the neighbor's wife take the rap for him or does he get arrested?

I didn't know Gwenyth could sing so well. I like Tim McGraw and think he's a fine actor. But hands down, for me, was Garrett Hedlund. I love his voice and his looks. He definitely rocks my boat!