Roy A

Horrible film. Salman Khan sleepwalked through the film, which is anyway 95% shot in front of green screen. Diehard Bhai fans and paid PR props upvoting the film and rating 5* does not change that.

Aamir's character appears to be near entirely a caricature. Many reviewers have pointed out that his performance is akin to PK 2.0, and that the child artist playing junior Lal (not to mention Kareena in her bit sized rule) overshadowed him. So his acting prowess lay threadbare. He is a mannerism-heavy, bygone star and much less of an actor.

The ending was hushed and therefore illogical. The entire outcome hangs from the chance incident on Naren lying about NOT frequenting the cafe where Maya works, and Maya's overenthusiastic coworker Prema suddenly blabbing everything to a rank unknown police officer whom she knew was there for murder investigation assignment. Just one caution from Maya to Prema, would have stopped this happening. All very very implausible.