Binge-worthy, yes, and slickly produced and impressively cast, this superduper HBO high-end concept soaper certainly aims for the stars: its problem is an uncertainty of tone and style which, by the end of the second season, murders the whole tale just as it crosses the finish line. And what is the point? Is it all a sly comment on the abrasive helicopter parenting campaigns waged by the fabulously dotcom rich of Pacific Coast Highway California? (By the way: why Monterey, and why not Santa Barbara? Why not Woodside, for that matter, or Menlo Park, or Palo Alto? Perhaps I'm ignorant of the California Lifestyles of the Rich, Self-Pampered and Megamaniacal). Is it all an examination of the ripple effects of sexual and emotional abuse? Is it a study of white privilege marriage at the turning point? Or is it all simply an item-list display of why red state deplorables despise blue state elites?
I suppose it works on all these levels. And yet one is left wondering, even so, at the tone. Is it a satire? A black comedy? A domestic drama? A social take-down? WHAT IS IT?
I don't think even exec producers Witherspoon and Kidman know, for overall the biggest giveaway lies in the performance of the magnetic, hypnotic, and yet all-wrong for this circus Ms. Laura Dern. Everything about her Renata Klein is a carefully conceived misfire: she's the abusive Mommie Dearest unchained, no matter that here she aims her rage at all except her own particular little Christina. In one take-down scene after another where her selfishness, screaming, scrambling and in particular her brand of blind rage scores shock laugh points (she ever but slenderly hath known herself), Ms. Dern's off-the-charts performance may be brave, but it destroys the central point, for she is, by far, the most extreme of the emotional abusers on this particular lot. She wins the Faye Dunaway Award here, with no other competition in range.
Watch it for Meryl Streep's sly performance, only slightly undone by a shift of tone, and for Nicole Kidman's rainbow of psychological wounds suffered at the hands of lunactic husband Alexander Skarsgård; you can give Reese Witherspoon's annoying performance a driveby view. But for me, the best element of the show is the one-and-only warmly sympathetic performance I know from the usual dragon-lady Robin Weigert, as the sometimes maligned shrink who actually has a handle on the particular maladies of these self-indulgent people.
And still, the lingering question remains: did the producers really not see that Laura Dern's Renata Klein is perhaps the biggest abuser of all? Watch her scene at the counter, ordering an Americana espresso, in one of the final scenes of Season 2 if you have any lingering doubt. Forget all about the troubled men (only the sensitive white-wine wimps score female approbation here) and zone in on Kidman's witchery, Streep's passive aggressive takedowns, Witherspoon's unending kvetching, and you may wind up wondering what it was all about. I certainly did.
I for one hope they're done, have said what they meant to say, and won't be returning for a Season 3 which cements for yet another 7 performances how little they've learned. And by the way, a final question: whatever happened to Max's bullying? Did he just, uh, suddenly stop? Could it have been all those excruciating intimacy scenes with Kidman, meant to convey that she really really really IS a good mother, after all? He was so terrified of another close-range bout of her tearful, moist-mother sloppiness that he just left his bullying behind?