Okay I just watched this movie and I loved it but I don’t think it deserves five stars I would give it just four because I hate it when I feel confused about something now I know vera loved william but she did have a thing with dylan too and it makes me frustrated that this chemistry between kiera knightley and cilian murphy because they didn’t get enough scenes it was mostly including dylan and his wife and I hated that it could have been magical if it was just vera and william’s story now my point of view says that first she had feelings for dylan and feeling nostalgic because they had a thing at their childhood which is a normal feeling when you meet someone you loved when you where a teenager but then when she met william she felt something for him but she didn’t want to admit that because she was afraid he was going to die and then her feelings started growing starting from the scene she said make love to me and then they got married and it was william the one she truly loved but she just had something for dylan and felt nostalgic but he wasn’t the one for her or maybe it was also about her brain because at the end when she asked dylan to save william from going to jail she said something which meant that william is better for her because he makes her feel real but anyways great movie great acting I choose to believe she loved william as she said I can’t live without him which is another way of saying You love someone and you can tell she really meant it and also there is something I always question in movies and even in real life why would you marry someone while you cant feel for them or while you have feelings for someone else why did dylan marry his wife? He didn’t seem to care about her at all and she obviously knew that and she was aware he totally loved vera and both of them slept with other people while they were married to each other so what’s the point of this damn marriage why don’t they get a divorce or simply why can’t two people just stay loyal to each other why can’t people have the dignity of if you can’t still be honestly devoted to this person just leave because it turns into a toxic relationship then and if he loves vera why did he marry someone else why did he sleep with other women is this called love? He may have feelings for her but it’s clearly not true love however, it’s been a long time since I watched something that made me question many things about the characters and their feelings and about everything and that’s what makes it an amazing movie because you can feel it not just watch it