Anyone giving this game fewer than 5-stars is not someone you should get into a discussion with. It is just not worth it. You may not like the genre or any other thing with this game, but it requires the utmost respect from the developers.
I have played games for the last 30 years of my life, and I am very quick and harsh in criticising games.
This is one of the fewest games that I did not skip all the small and minor side objectives and missions. I played them all. Not all of them are very good, and there are definitely many things that could've been better, but overall superb!
I would love to watch this story as tv-series, but I doubt that anyone can do better in a cinematic world than what is already done for the game.
The music, the feeling it gives to you, is incredible. I stayed in many locations on the map for hours and listened to music, enjoying the view. It will be too long if I start a review, but I loved almost all parts of this game.
The acting, the soundtracks, and the story WOW! The ending was perfect. The combat scenes and the weather. Also, the wind navigating you around is another thing that seems minor but changes the game's feeling. For example, in RDR2, I hate moving around. It doesn't give me the feeling this game is giving.
I'll just shut up. Experience this masterpiece.