Story: 4/5. Spike Lee really is just a very good filmmaker, isn't he? I thought I knew what I was in for when I started this, and I was so wrong. This isn't your standard Vietnam movie at all. This is a layered and emotional story about black men and their place throughout the historic fight for equality while being entirely earthed in their sense of belonging and relationships. The relationships at the core of this story are what make it all worth it, and those relationships are strong as hell. The men are all fleshed out gradually and with care, finding their place in the viewer's eyes and heart as the story moves along seamlessly. Delroy Lindo as Paul is so amazing in his role that he almost makes it impossible for the rest of the cast to shine, even though they do a great job as well. But really, Delroy Lindo was made for this role. Clarke Peters as Otis was also a standout. This is a difficult film at times, dealing with harsh subject matters, but it handles all of them well. My only gripe is with its mention of women without showing their important input, which could have done with a bit more work.
Visuals: 4/5. This is a film with a lot of mixed media and that could have been tacky but it is handled masterfully here. The film has a look to it and it is maintained throughout. The use of different aspect ratios was a clever choice for the flashbacks. The images gave it a documentary feel in a good way. The production design as a whole was great and it felt like being in Vietnam the entire way through. The special effects were all grounded and believable. The cinematography was never particularly flashy but consistent and appropriate, with Paul's monologue being pretty intense.
Sound: 4/5. War movies often have a theme to their scores and this score shares parts of that as if paying homage, but allows itself to have a necessary softness to its story, too. The softness complements the tone of this story and allows for the humour to work really well, too. The sound design was great throughout. The sound editing was cleverly worked into the visual editing in a very pleasing way.
12/15: This is so much more than a war film; it is a reflection on war and trauma and history and it does that amazingly.