Jo Griffiths

I think it's beautiful to look at and very atmospheric and Emma is a very good Emily with her slightly unconventional beauty. However I hate the fact that the film suggests Emily was inspired to write Wuthering Heights because of her love and the loss of William. Emily wrote from her vivid interior life and imagination.....she didn't need a man to galvanise her. She was known to have had no romantic entanglement and it's a real shame that the writer/director thought it necessary to include a love interest and couldn't let her stand on her own merits without adding a man into the mix.

I really like this. I like the improvised feel of it. I like the fact things take a while to develop. The relationship between David and Grace is really funny as she keeps holding him to account and makes him explain and won't let him get away with anything. It's refreshing as a period drama - bit like Taboo. People criticise it because nothing happens but that's what I like.

Entertaining, but basically trying to be a Guy Ritchie film and failing. No wonder Jason Statham decided against it.