"I Am Racist" has been widely panned for its problematic execution and lack of depth. The film is criticized for being overly provocative without offering substantial insight into racism. Its portrayal of racial issues is seen as superficial and exploitative, with the film reducing complex social problems to sensationalist shock value. The narrative is criticized for being disjointed and lacking genuine character development, leaving audiences feeling more bewildered than engaged. Overall, the film is viewed as an irresponsible and failed attempt at addressing a serious subject, ultimately missing the opportunity to foster meaningful dialogue.