I think some of the judges are so wrong. The one in season 2 where Brooke won against Jose Garces was horrendous. Same when Michael Symon received a 5!!!! That judge was really really bad. Don't get me wrong, I love all the chefs but come on. I gave it a chance again after the Michael Symon fiasco but then when Brooke won against Jose, mind you even she knew she shouldn't have won, that was it for me.
Sorry Bobby Flay.... you needed to have vetted your judges better ๐