before i start, i wanna say that karen is an AMAZING author. the way her mind must work in order for these books of hers to always work/make sense is beyond me. that being said, in comparison to one of us is lying, this book was a bit (i say a bit because it wasnt TOTALLY, but still) predictable, honestly. there were a lot of subtle hints that could lead you to figuring out what happened (at least partly) before you get the big reveal. whereas in one of us is lying, it was a complete shock. im also incredibly mad at the cliffhanger, and there should DEFINITELY be a third book, or some kind of follow up to further explain things. with all that being said, loved the book and the plot and her writing continues to blow me away.