When I studied film criticism in college, I had this professor who basically detested the concept of plot in a film. She was of the opinion that all films should be meandering studies of themes, driven by the emotions of the characters and that the events which take place during the run of the film are incidental.
She probably loved this smoldering train wreck.
True story: A particularly shiftless sloth on a handful of dilaudid told me he thought the pacing of this film was painfully slow. But pacing implies that one is on a journey, en route to an eventual destination. Can one justifiably gripe about pacing if the film just isnโt ever going anywhere? American Honey is a meandering, plotless, pointless character study of a group of thinly drawn, pernicious yet pathetic characters whom are totally inauthentic and exist more as a collection of tropes than anything else. Iโm a native Floridian, Iโm acclimated to being surrounded by trashy, obnoxious, gun-toting ignorance and youโd need a flamethrower to compel me to get in a van with those characters. Speaking of authenticity, American Honey is completely lacking in it. The film is about middle America as much as itโs about anything and the director Andrea Arnold, a British woman, appears as though her only experience of the United States is eating scones for breakfast and reading the Guardian. No, one cannot run around the suburbs in the middle of the day waving a pistol around without the police getting called. No, there arenโt roving bands of middle-aged cowboy caricatures prowling the streets in vintage Cadillacs looking for girls to rape and no, you canโt have a shootout with them in the backyard without consequences.
Perhaps the most tragically inept scene in this movie misadventure is one in which Star (Sasha Lane) and Jake (Shia Lebouf) con their way into an idyllic suburban home in which a preteen girl is having a party with her friends. I think Arnold was trying to make a point about the crass and shallow sexuality of contemporary pop culture and the role it plays in the sexualization of children. To say that it fails badly in the opposite direction is a fantastic understatement. What we get is another interminable scene featuring a group of twerking ten-year-olds trying to give Shia Lebouf a boner. Itโs infinitely worse than the raunchiest Carbi B song.
The fact that American Honey won the jury prize at Cannes, was nominated for a BAFTA and is generally lauded by film critics not a validation of the film but a testament to the enthusiastically self-imposed irrelevancy of those institutions and individuals.
This thing is flat-out bad, I recommend skipping it.